No, No, No …

Posted by Scott McClellan on April 29th, 2008 at 8:58 am

We talked before about the fine line between stealing and creativity (here and here), but I wanted to share this egregious violation of intellectual property law and common decency. You can find the long version of the story here in a blog post titled “Christian Thieves,” but I’ll give you the Reader’s Digest version. Basically, a designer/blogger named Jimi designed a really cool T-shirt graphic he named “Revelations.” While one T-shirt company paid him for the right to print and sell shirts featuring his design, a Christian T-shirt company just grabbed the design (either off a shirt or the web) and began selling it.

Sigh.

After the Christian T-shirt company was bombarded by hate mail from Jimi’s fans and friends, the company took down the shirt and apologized (in other words, they stopped when they got caught). While apologies are all well and good, the way I see it, the damage has been done, the company’s reputation is foreverĀ  ruined, and we have to add another incident to the Christians Behaving Badly list.

So why do people who worship the Creator of the universe shy away from creating? Why do people who argue for the Ten Commandments to appear in public buildings (and on network TV) ignore “Thou Shalt Not Steal” when it suits them? I’m not sure. You could suggest the “fallen people/fallen world” idea, but that doesn’t quite work for me this time. Instead, I propose that we as broken people work toward building a Church where it isn’t acceptable to associate theft and Christianity. As church leaders who regularly employ technology and the arts, let that work begin with us.

8 Responses to “No, No, No …”

Matt, here is a link to the conversation over at Emptees regarding this whole situation. Jimi actually posted the apology email the guy sent. It’s people like that who give “Creative Christians” a bad name…or even a name at all. http://emptees.com/posts/2754-major-major-manticores-thanks-removed

posted at 9:14 am on April 29th, 2008 by Dan

I just found a photo that we shot of our kids ministry in a web ad on Gospelcom. It’s CC licensed as “all rights reserved”. They just pulled it from Flickr.

I am so gonna give them a piece of my mind today!

posted at 10:38 am on April 29th, 2008 by Allan White

Another angle: I’m having to be really, really careful with the worship media I create. I’m giving away some on my site (Worship Media category in the blog) - but only those that are completely original creations. Occasionally I’ve used free media, and declared when I have done so. The easiest way to avoid this problem is to shoot stills and video myself - free and clear.

Some media that I create from other sources (modified stock, for example) I only use during performances and don’t distribute them.

As I’ve considered creating media for sale, this issue has become more front-and-center for me. We’re responsible for taking the high road as believers.

posted at 10:47 am on April 29th, 2008 by Allan White

One more thought: this is one of the areas that should be covered in school when people are studying design. I think the rise of the internet and self-taught designers has led many to take “the Dark Side” - faster, easier. More powerful, it is not!

posted at 10:49 am on April 29th, 2008 by Allan White

This would get much more attention from the “Christian mainstream” if it had anything to do with homosexuality, going green, or Hillary Clinton, or Oprah, or The Golden Compass, or (insert useless boycott here).

The big problem with creative Christians, or just Christians for that matter is it is difficult to stay connected to our ever creative Creator but easy to click…click…click. Let’s just say that something is bad, and not create anything good, it’s easier. When someone does create something good, ah…just mimic it. Have you been in a “Christian Bookstore” (Ugh) lately? Gotta love those Jesus died for Myspace in heaven t-shirts. C’mon, Christ followers get a clue!!!

I love you.

posted at 2:11 pm on April 29th, 2008 by the randy

Yea, I don’t get it either… “Christians” in name only.

Well I just ordered the legit t-shirt from DBH, so I’m doing what I can to support the artist!

posted at 3:07 pm on April 29th, 2008 by Dan (djByron)

[…] opposed to the design thievery I mentioned yesterday, fresh/creative/orginal/quality design is a good thing. Not only does good […]

posted at 1:21 pm on April 30th, 2008 by Collide Magazine » Blog Archive » Good Design, On The Other Hand ...

This situation is indicative of secular culture’s attitude to piracy becoming part of current church culture. While part of it is ignorance (do older clergy even understand that this happens or how this happens so they may address it?), I think the rest it is a new way of stealing. It just doesn’t replicate the physical act of shoplifting, busting a door, grabbing a purse, etc. so people, both “Christians” and not, seem comfortable justifying their actions.
But this really goes back to relying on God for His provision, right? How many pastors/youth pastors/church workers have asked me to make a copy of a purchased music CD for them—and justified it with, “well, I’m in ministry, I can’t afford it otherwise”? The same line is now given to me when young adults in church ministry ask if I can help them illegally acquire electronic media and programs of all kinds. Yet I know they wouldn’t walk out of the building with the church laptop.
Seriously, this must be addressed in churches immediately.

posted at 6:03 am on May 23rd, 2008 by Secret Latte

Leave A Comment





Church Media Group, Inc.